|Report of the U.S. Delegate, Codex Committee on Contaminants in Food, 5th Session
The 5th session of CCCF met in The Hague, The Netherlands, March 21-25, 2011, at the kind invitation of
the Government of The Netherlands. The meeting was attended by 184 delegates representing 62 member
countries, one member organization, and 15 international organizations.
Matters Referred to the Committee by the Codex Alimentarius Commission and/or Other Codex Committee/Task
Proposal for Revision of the Definition of Hazard in the Procedural Manual
- Revision of Risk Analysis Principles Applied by the Codex Committee on Food Additives and the Codex
Committee on Contaminants in Foods and the Code of Practice for Source Directed Measures to Reduce
Contamination of Food with Chemicals as to their applicability to animal feed
The Committee agreed to establish an eWG led by The Netherlands with the following terms of reference:
- To prepare separate Risk Analysis Principles for contaminants and natural toxins in food and feed;
- To examine whether it was necessary to further specify the applicability to feed in the Principles
as well as the Code of Practice as proposed in Annexes 1 and 2 of CS/CF 11/52, respectively; taking
into account the proposal for the amendment of the definition of contaminant as presented in CRD 18;
- To consider any other revisions that might be necessary to update the terminology in the Principles
for consistency with the current risk assessment terminology.
- Noting that the proposal was in relation to nutrient risk assessment and the decision of the 32nd
session of the Committee on Nutrition and Foods for Special Dietary Uses not to amend the definition,
the Committee agreed that further discussion on this matter was no longer necessary.
Standard for Olive Oils and Olive Pomace Oils
The Committee concluded that halogenated solvents could be considered as processing aids and therefore
did not fall within the remit of the CCCF. The Committee also noted that solvents were only allowed
for the production of olive pomace oils according to the Standard for Olive Oils and Olive Pomace Oils
(CODEX STAN 33-1981) and that the presence of these solvents in olive oil and virgin olive oil would be
considered as contaminants. The Committee agreed to request CCFO to consider whether the use of
halogenated solvents in the production of olive pomace oils was necessary in view of the potential
health concerns associated with these compounds and the consequential general trend to reduce their
Entries for fat spreads and blended spreads in the GSCTFF
The Committee agreed to replace "margarine and minarine" with "fat spreads and blended spreads"
as proposed by CCFO.
Proposed Draft Code of Practice for the Reduction of Ethyl Carbamate in Stone Fruit Distillates
The Committee agreed to forward the proposed draft Code of Practice to the 34th Session of the
Commission for adoption at Step 5/8 (with omission of Steps 6 and 7).
Draft Maximum Levels for Melamine in Food (Liquid Infant Formula)
The Committee agreed to forward the draft ML of 0.15 mg/kg for liquid infant formula as consumed
(with a note that the ML does not apply to liquid infant formula for which it can be proven that the
level higher than the ML is a consequence of migration from food contact materials taking into account
any nationally authorized migration limit) to the 34th Session of the Commission for adoption at
Step 5/8 (with the omission of Steps 6 and 7). The Delegations of Costa Rica, Peru, and Nicaragua
expressed their reservation to the inclusion of the note.
Proposed Draft Maximum Levels for Deoxynivalenol (DON) and its Acetylated Derivatives in Cereals
and Cereal-based Products
The Committee agreed to proceed with the establishment of MLs for DON in cereals and that it would at
the 8th Session of the Committee consider the extension of the ML to acetylated derivatives. The
Committee reconfirmed that the ML would not be for cereals intended for animal feed as DON barely
carries over to animal products for human consumption. The Committee also agreed to reconvene the
eWG, led by Canada, to continue this work, including the development of associated sampling plans,
exploration of the possibility to revise the existing Code of Practice for the Prevention and Reduction
of Mycotoxin Contamination in Cereals (CAC/RCP 51-2003), and requesting CCMAS to identify methods for
acetylated derivatives of DON.
The Committee agreed to return the propose draft MLs for DON to Step 2/3 for further development by the
eWG, circulation for comments and further consideration by the next session of the Committee.
Proposed Draft Maximum Level for Total Aflatoxins in Dried Figs
The Committee agreed to return the Proposed Draft Maximum Level for Total Aflatoxins in Dried Figs to Step
2/3 so that the sampling plans according to the proposed ML of 10 mg/kg can be developed for further
consideration by the next session of the Committee.
Editorial Amendments to the GSCTFF
The Committee agreed to discuss this Agenda Item at the next session as there was no document available
at this session.
Discussion Paper on Mycotoxins in Sorghum
The Committee agreed to re-establish the eWG, led by Nigeria, to update the discussion paper to screen
the general part of the existing Code of Practice for the Prevention and Reduction of Mycotoxin
Contamination in Cereals (CAC/RCP 51-2003) to ascertain whether it was relevant and feasible for the
production of sorghum and to explore the feasibility of including an additional Annex for "Prevention
and reduction of contamination by aflatoxins in grain sorghum" to the COP for consideration by the next
session of the Committee.
Discussion Paper on Arsenic in Rice
The Committee agreed to initiate new work on maximum levels for arsenic in rice subject to approval by
the 34th Session of the Commission. The Committee also agreed to re-convene the eWG led by China, who
would prepare a working paper considering MLs for arsenic in rice based on the considerations made at
plenary for deliberation at the next session of the Committee. The eWG should specify whether the MLs
apply to total and/or inorganic arsenic in rice.
Discussion Paper on Guidance for Risk Management Options on How to Deal with the Results from New Risk
The Committee agreed to re-establish the eWG, led by the United States of America and co-chaired by The
Netherlands, to revise the discussion paper with the following terms of reference:
- Prepare a discussion paper for consideration at the next session of the Committee on risk management
options, in addition to MLs and codes of practice, in light of different risk assessment outcomes
- A description of different risk assessment outcomes in language understandable for risk managers;
- Implications of different risk assessment outcomes and description of possible risk management
Discussion Paper on Ochratoxin A in Cocoa
The Committee agreed to re-establish the eWG, led by Ghana, to update the discussion paper with a view
to the development of a code of practice for consideration by the next session of the Committee.
Discussion Paper on Furan
The Committee noted that to date research on furan had not been successful in identifying practical
and consistently effective solutions for decreasing furan in food and that it was premature to develop
a code of practice at this stage. The Committee agreed that this work could be taken up in the future
when more adequate data become available and that at that time the re-establishment of the eWG to
further develop the discussion paper could be considered.
Discussion Paper on Pyrrolizidine Alkaloids
The Committee agreed to re-establish the eWG, led by The Netherlands, to undertake further compilation
of existing management practices to evaluate the possibility to develop a code of practice for further
consideration by the next session of the Committee.
Endorsement of Provisions for Health-related Limits for Certain Substances in the Standard for Natural
Noting that according to the Natural Mineral Water Standard, the compounds in sections 3.2.17 to 3.2.20
should not be present in natural mineral waters but permitted at levels below the LOQ, and the general
sense of the Committee that the compounds in sections 3.2.17 to 3.2.20 should therefore be considered
quality parameters, it was agreed to inform the Commission to remove footnote 3 in the Standard on
Natural Mineral Waters (CODEX STAN 108-1981) as there was no need for the endorsement of these sections
since there was no safety concern associated with these compounds at the proposed levels. The
Committee took no further action on the integration of the safety parameters in sections 3.2.1 to
3.2.16 into the General Standard on Contaminants and Toxins in Food and Feed.
Priority List of Contaminants and Naturally Occurring Toxicants Proposed for Evaluation by JECFA
The Committee noted that fumonisins and cyanogenic glycosides were scheduled for evaluation by the
74th JECFA (June 2011) and therefore removed them from the priority list. The Committee endorsed the
priority list of contaminants and naturally occurring toxicants for JECFA evaluation as noted below:
- 3-MCPD esters – Full evaluation (toxicological and exposure assessments)
- Glycidyl esters – Full evaluation (toxicological and exposure assessments) and bioavailability of
- Pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs) – Identify most relevant PAs (occurrence and toxicity) for human
health, full risk assessment, identify data gaps, consideration of PAs in food as it carries over from
feed to animal products
- Non dioxin-like PCBs
Other Business and Future Work
Report of the In-session Working Group on the Follow-up by CCCF on Recent JECFA Evaluations
- Maximum levels for cadmium in various foods in the Codex General Standard for Contaminants and Toxins
in Food and Feed and the related Code of Practice for Source Directed Measures to Reduce Contamination
of Foods with Chemicals
The Committee agreed that no follow-up was necessary.
- Maximum levels for lead in various foods in the Codex General Standard for Contaminants and Toxins
in Food and Feed and the related Code of Practice for the Prevention and Reduction of Lead
Contamination in Foods and the Code of Practice for Source Directed Measures to Reduce Contamination of
Foods with Chemicals
The Committee agreed to establish an eWG, led by the United States of America, to (i) reconsider the
existing maximum levels with a focus on foods important for infants and children and also on the canned
fruits and vegetables and (ii) reconsider if other existing maximum levels should be addressed.
- Maximum levels for mercury in natural mineral water and salt (food grade) and guideline levels for
methylmercury in fish and predatory fish in the Codex General Standard for Contaminants and Toxins in
Food and Feed and the related Code of Practice for Source Directed Measures to Reduce Contamination of
Foods with Chemicals
The Committee agreed that no follow-up as regards the existing MLs for mercury was necessary. The
Committee also agreed to consider the need to review the existing GLs for methylmercury in predatory
fish when the full report of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Consultation on the Risks and Benefits of Fish
Consumption becomes available.
The Committee agreed that no follow-up was necessary since no health concern was identified at current
estimated levels of exposure from food and drinking water.
- Chlorine-containing disinfectants in food production and processing
The Committee took note of the report of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Meeting on the Benefits and Risks of
the Use of Chlorine-containing Disinfectants in Food Production and Processing and agreed that no
further action was necessary.
April 12, 2011